Turntables

Three ways to build a turntable

There are three sound ideas about how a turntable should deal with vibration, and Linn, Rega and Clearaudio each stand for one of them. McIntosh and Luxman build on the same ideas in their own way, and Technics answers a different question altogether: how the platter is turned. Knowing the ideas makes it easier to see which turntable will suit you.

The job

A record groove is read by a stylus that responds to any movement at all. The music is one source of movement. The motor, the bearing, the loudspeakers and the floor are others, and the stylus cannot tell them apart. Every turntable is an answer to one question: what do you do with the vibration you do not want?

There are three honest answers. Keep it away from the record by floating the working parts on springs. Give it nowhere to linger by making the structure light and stiff. Or soak it up with mass, damping and a bearing that barely touches. The three makers we know best each chose one.

Linn: float it on springs

Inside the Sondek LP12's plinth, a metal sub-chassis hangs from three springs. The platter bearing and the tonearm are both fixed to that sub-chassis, so the record and the arm move as one, separated from the plinth, the shelf and the motor, which is bolted to the top plate outside the suspended part. The platter turns on a single-point bearing in oil and is driven by a belt.

The idea has not changed since 1972, and neither have the dimensions that matter. That is the LP12's other strength. Every sub-chassis, bearing, power supply and arm Linn has developed since fits a deck of any age, so the turntable can be improved one part at a time for as long as you own it.

What it asks: skilled setup. The springs are tuned until the suspended parts move freely and evenly, and the deck is left to settle before its final adjustment. Every LP12 we build is set up, settled and adjusted on our bench.

Majik, Selekt and Klimax →   How the Sondek LP12 works →   Plan the next step for an LP12 →

Rega: make it light and stiff

Rega's founder, Roy Gandy, has long described a turntable as a measuring instrument, and the book Rega published on its own designs is titled A Vibration Measuring Machine. The reasoning runs against instinct. A heavy structure stores vibration and lets it out slowly, which blurs the sound. Rega's answer is to take mass out and put stiffness in.

You can see it in the product. A Planar plinth is thin and light, with a brace on top and another beneath tying the platter bearing to the tonearm mount, the one distance that must never change. On the Planar 8 and Planar 10 the plinth is cut back to a skeleton, with a foam core between thin, hard laminate skins.

What it asks: a good place to stand. With no suspension and very little mass, a Rega takes on the character of whatever is under it, which is why Rega makes a wall bracket for its turntables. What it gives back is simplicity. There is nothing to tune, and a Planar with its cartridge fitted at the factory needs little more than its balance weight and tracking force set.

Rega turntables: the Planar range →   Rega turntables, arms and cartridges →   Build your Rega Planar →

Clearaudio: mass, damping and a platter that floats

Clearaudio, of Erlangen in Germany, takes the third road. Its turntables are built from dense, well-damped materials: thick platters of engineering polymer, on the larger models over a stainless steel sub-platter, and chassis made as a sandwich of aluminum and Panzerholz, a compressed wood laminate. Clearaudio calls these shapes resonance-optimized.

The signature idea is the Ceramic Magnetic Bearing, patented in 2006. Opposing magnets carry the platter's weight, so it floats, and a polished ceramic shaft keeps it centered. With no thrust point bearing the load there is very little friction and very little bearing noise. On many models an optical sensor reads the platter's speed and corrects it continuously.

What it asks: careful assembly and alignment, which we do here in the store, and a solid, level surface. What it gives back is a turntable with nothing to tune, made with the precision of a machine tool.

Clearaudio turntables: from the Compass to the Statement →   Clearaudio turntables, arms and cartridges →   Build your Clearaudio Signature →

McIntosh: the floating platter, made with Clearaudio

McIntosh's MT5 and MT10 belong to the same family of ideas as Clearaudio's turntables, and that is no accident. McIntosh and Clearaudio worked together to build them. A visitor's account of Clearaudio's factory in The Ear mentions seeing McIntosh models among the work in progress there.

What you see is pure McIntosh. A platter of silicon acrylic, lit green from below, rides on a magnetically suspended ceramic bearing above a black glass plinth. Opposed magnets carry most of the platter's weight, so the bearing surfaces carry almost none. The MT10 adds a brushless motor with electronic braking and an illuminated speed meter in the style of McIntosh's power meters.

What it asks: very little. The tonearm and cartridge are fitted and aligned at the factory. What it gives back is a turntable that belongs with a McIntosh system, in its looks and in the way it switches on with the rest of the system.

The MTI100 takes a different route to the same end. It is a belt-drive turntable with a vacuum tube preamplifier, a phono stage and an amplifier built in, so that it needs only loudspeakers.

McIntosh turntables: the MT2, MT5 and MT10 →   McIntosh analog at Pearl →

Luxman: a heavy platter, held to speed

Luxman's PD-151 MKII and PD-191A use neither springs nor magnets. Each puts a heavy platter of machined aluminum, 4 kg on the PD-151 MKII and 5.2 kg on the PD-191A, on a 16 mm stainless steel spindle. On the PD-191A the working parts hang beneath a 15 mm aluminum plate, with the motor and transformer set apart on a damped plate of their own.

Speed is the other half of the design. A brushless motor is held to speed by a control circuit that measures and corrects continuously, and each of the three speeds, 33⅓, 45 and 78, can be trimmed by up to 6 percent.

The PD-191A carries the LTA-710, a ten-inch tonearm with a knife-edge bearing that Luxman developed with SAEC. It takes a standard headshell, so a second cartridge can be fitted in a minute.

What it asks: a solid, level surface and a cartridge of your choosing. What it gives back is mass, calm and precision, in a turntable built to the standard of Luxman's amplifiers.

With a Luxman turntable we stay with Luxman for the phono stage: the E-250 or the E-07, or the phono stage built into a Luxman integrated amplifier. The L-505Z, L-507Z, L-509Z and L-100 Centennial each have moving-magnet and moving-coil inputs, and the L-509Z has two moving-coil inputs, high and low, as the E-250 does.

Luxman turntables →

Technics: take the belt away

Every turntable above turns its platter with a belt. Technics does not. In a direct-drive turntable the platter sits on the motor itself, so there is no belt to stretch or slip. Technics has built direct-drive turntables since 1970.

The old objection to direct drive was cogging, a faint unevenness as the motor's poles pass. The current Technics motors are coreless: there is no iron in the stator, so there is nothing to cog. The SL-1500C and SL-1200GR2 use a single rotor. The SL-1200G places the coils between two rotors and adds a three-layer platter of brass, aluminum and rubber. The SL-1000R, the reference, carries a platter of 7.9 kg.

The tonearm follows the classic Technics pattern on every model: a static-balance S-shaped arm on gimbal bearings, with a headshell that unplugs. The tube is aluminum on the SL-1500C and SL-1200GR2 and magnesium on the SL-1200G, and the SL-1000R has a ten-inch arm. With the auxiliary weights supplied, the SL-1200G's arm balances cartridges from 5.6 g to nearly 20 g. Hi-Fi News measured the SL-1200GR2's arm at 8 to 9 g effective mass with its headshell, which suits most moving magnets and medium-compliance moving coils.

The SL-1500C arrives with an Ortofon 2M Red fitted. Further up the range, owners often choose Ortofon's 2M Black or a Cadenza moving coil, the Hana SL or ML, or the Sumiko Moonstone, and Stereophile's reviewer used an Ortofon Cadenza Bronze and a Hana Umami Red on the SL-1200G. Because the headshell unplugs, it is easy to keep two cartridges, each on its own headshell.

What it asks: very little. Fit the headshell, set the balance weight and tracking force, and play. What it gives back is steady pitch and a platter that reaches speed in 0.7 seconds.

Technics turntables →

Side by side

Linn Sondek LP12Rega PlanarClearaudioMcIntosh MT5, MT10LuxmanTechnics
The ideaIsolate it: platter and arm float together on springsDo not store it: low mass, high stiffnessAbsorb it: mass, damping, a magnetic bearingThe floating platter, in McIntosh formMass and control: a heavy platter held to speedDrive the platter directly, with no belt
The structureHardwood plinth, sprung metal sub-chassisThin braced plinth, a skeleton with a foam core on the Planar 8 and 10Dense polymer platter, aluminum and Panzerholz chassisSilicon acrylic platter on a magnetic ceramic bearingMachined aluminum platter on a thick aluminum plateCoreless direct-drive motor under a die-cast platter
SetupBuilt and tuned on our benchLittle: balance weight and tracking forceAssembled and aligned in the storeArm and cartridge aligned at the factoryTonearm fitted, cartridge chosen separatelyLittle: headshell, balance weight, tracking force
What goes under itA light, rigid, level table, or a wall shelfA rigid shelf. Rega makes a wall bracketA solid, level surfaceA solid, level surfaceA solid, level surfaceA solid, level surface

More on what goes under a turntable: Where the turntable sits.

Which is yours

None of these is the right answer for everyone. Each is a sound idea carried through with conviction.

  • If you want to buy once and keep improving it, and you like the thought of a turntable built by hand for you, look at the Sondek LP12.
  • If you want a great deal of music for little fuss, start with a Rega Planar.
  • If you are drawn to precision engineering and want to choose your own arm and cartridge, look at Clearaudio.
  • If your system is McIntosh and you want the turntable to match it and arrive ready to play, look at the MT5 and MT10.
  • If you want a heavy, calm, finely made machine with adjustable speed and an arm that takes a standard headshell, look at Luxman.
  • If you want to put a record on and have it at speed in under a second, with steady pitch and almost nothing to adjust, look at Technics.

Tell us what you listen to and what the turntable will play through, and we can talk through which approach suits you. Call (503) 222-2599, email sales@pearlaudio.com, or arrange an audition.

Sources: Linn's Sondek LP12 owner's manual; Rega and Roy Gandy as reported by Stereophile, The Absolute Sound and What Hi-Fi?; Clearaudio's own published descriptions and hi-fi+; McIntosh's and Luxman's published specifications; SoundStage! Ultra's review of the MT10; The Ear's visit to the Clearaudio factory; Technics' published specifications; the Hi-Fi News lab report on the SL-1200GR2; Stereophile's review of the SL-1200G.

More on turntables

By maker

Search